Words by Jimmy Dougan / Production images and artwork supplied by The Crescent Theatre Company
Anyone looking for a masterclass in theatrical form ought to get down to the Crescent as soon as possible. In this production of Nina Raine’s dreadfully topical 2017 smash Consent, director Andrew Cowie takes big ideas and wrestles them into a sleek staging that’s lean, muscular and relentlessly provocative.
This is the way real stories are told: even if I remain as ambivalent about Raine’s play as I was back in 2017, this is audacious and thrilling theatre.
Raine’s play is unapologetically old-fashioned. It opens in the home of new parents Kitty and Ed (Grace Cheatle and Scott Westwood), sipping wine with their lawyer friends Jake and Rachel (James David Knapp and Perdita Lawton – both wickedly funny). The latter are evidently at their wit’s end with their marriage, and Cowie mines some great gags from their polite barbing.
Meanwhile, Kitty is trying to set her actress friend Zara (Steph Urquhart) up with one of Ed’s prosecuting-counsel colleagues Tim (Mark Payne).
Ed and Tim soon find themselves locking horns in court. Ed is defending an accused rapist, with Tim heading the prosecution. The victim, Gayle (Katie Merriman), is virtually ignored in proceedings. As Tim agonisingly explains to her, she is effectively a witness in her own rape. She is evidence. It’s better that a guilty man goes free than an innocent one goes down, he reminds her. Why? Gayle asks. He has no answer.
Cowie’s direction distils this premise into a series of short, snappy scenes which manage to keep Raine’s occasionally laboured dialogue from feeling strained. There is a roughness to the production, a deliberately unfinished quality: the bare black wall of the Crescent’s Ron Barber Studio is exposed, and the playing space is a simple white platform with a visible props table adjacent to it.
What this does is deftly reflect the unfinished, ongoing nature of debates around women’s rights and legal protections. The actors are lit starkly from above, and Cowie and Raine ask us to play jury. When they’re not on stage, the actors sit at the edge of the playing space and watch incuriously, suggesting the roles we perform in public and private.
A shame that in such a versatile space Cowie opts to place us end-on to the action; from the back row I felt distant. Cowie’s blocking is tight, but you can’t help but notice the smallness of the playing area and the physicality subsequently feels hemmed in.
I remain mixed on Raine’s play. It premiered in 2017, right before the eruption of the #MeToo movement, and Raine famously refused to update it for a West End transfer in 2018.
The fact the words ‘Me’ and ‘Too’ remain unsaid for the two hours of Raine’s play feels jarring in 2024, and Raine ends the first act of Consent with a Christmastime confrontation that’s so implausible as to verge on melodrama – though knowing what was coming, I was able to savour Merriman’s performance.
Fortunately, these issues are easy to forget watching an ensemble this game. They don’t just rise to the challenges of Rain’s script, they pin them to the ground to deliver some of the finest performances I’ve seen in the theatre. And Cowie’s subtle and assured direction finds a beautiful shape for their work to take.
While Consent hasn’t aged particularly well, the knotty issues at the core of its drama remain as dreadfully topical as ever.
Consent runs at the Crescent Theatre from 8-15 June 2024, presented by The Crescent Theatre Company in the Ron Barber Studio. Tickers are priced from £11.
For times and links to online ticket sales, click here.
For more from the Crescent Theatre, including full programme details and links to online ticket sales, visit www.crescent-theatre.co.uk